Cities: The Unsung Heroes at COP-21

By Chris Pieper, undergraduate student at Macalester College in St. Paul, Minnesota

We arrived back in St. Paul, Minnesota on a cold December afternoon, after spending a week enjoying the comparatively mild weather of Paris, France. In Paris, we joined tens of thousands of people, including around 150 world leaders, who convened on the quiet Parisian suburb of Le Bourget as part of The United Nation’s 21st Conference of the Parties, or COP-21, to negotiate an international climate agreement to fight global warming. We didn’t know it then, but what would become known as the Paris Agreement was finally worked out and ratified on December 12, 2015, one week after we got back to St. Paul.

I had the opportunity to attend this COP negotiation to conduct research with my university, Macalester College in St. Paul, Minnesota. At COP, I was interested in finding the “unsung heroes” of climate action. I was looking for those people or organizations quietly working behind the scenes and below the formalities of the international delegations to advance action against global warming.

It wasn’t long before I found what I was looking for: cities.

They’re probably the last thing one would think of at the mention of an international negotiation. Nonetheless, cities were very present at COP-21. Discussions on local action seemed to follow me everywhere. Cities had their own pavilion in the Climate Generations exposition center next-door. A convention of local leaders was convened on December 4th at Paris’s City Hall, where nearly a thousand city leaders met and agreed on action steps. One morning, after passing through security and checking in for the day, I walked aimlessly across the convention hall, and stumbled upon the mayors of Bristol (UK), Sydney (Australia), Addis Ababa (Ethiopia), and Rotterdam (Netherlands) speaking about urban resiliency at a panel discussion.

COP veterans who have been at many conferences before told me that the focus on cities is relatively new; even a few years ago, there wasn’t this intense focus on the actions of local entities. After speaking to a number of experts and mayors themselves, I began to understand why the world is turning to cities to lead the way in continuing the climate fight.

Cities are in a unique position for dealing with climate change: They are the world’s main carbon emitters, emitting around 70% of the world’s carbon, according to UN Habitat. This means their impact can have significant effects on reducing emissions worldwide. Cities also feel the impacts of climate change especially acutely, and will be at the forefront of future adaptation. On top of it all, it is predicted that by 2030 over two-thirds of the world’s population will live in cities, giving cities even more power to take significant action.

Local government is where it’s at,” proclaimed Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf at a discussion hosted by the US Center. 

If you can get enough cities to contribute to climate change, that can potentially have a bigger effect than some of the wimpier national commitments.Rotterdam’s mayor agrees,

The cities- we feel the urgency,”says Mayor Ahmed Aboutaleb. “Our cities are taking action, whether it’s public transport, water management, how to deal with resiliency in a wider sense with social issues, etc, a lot of things are going on.”

Aside from individual commitments, cities are pledging to take action together, as the Climate Summit for Local Leaders on December 4th demonstrated. It was a busy day for those who attended. Nearly 1,000 local leaders met and signed a Paris Hall Declaration to reduce emissions, reinforced an earlier Compact of Mayors with ambitious emissions targets, and worked alongside groups like the C40 group of cities, ICLEI (Local Governments for Sustainability) and UCLG (United Cities and Local Governments). Alongside these and other organizations, UCLG has been a key group in helping promote climate action locally by promoting and empowering local leaders, and its President, Kadir Topbaş, took a leading role at this unprecedented gathering of local leaders.

In addition to the action cities have been taking, cities are hotbeds for technical and financial innovation, and they’re often the first place where new ideas are tested before being scaled-up to the national level. “Cities,” says Mayor Schaaf, “prove it can be done. We create the evidence that these things actually can- that human behavior- can be changed. That there are innovative ways to pay for these changes. And we can kind of be the ‘testing grounds’ for different practices and create not just the political momentum, but the proof that it works.”

Finally, cities are the places where much of the national climate action is implemented. With the vast majority of people living in urban areas, climate action cannot be effectively undertaken without involving cities.

After the agreement is reached, who’s going to be the first to start implementing that?  It’s going to be the mayors at their desks the next morning” said Jeffrey Sachs of Columbia University’s Earth Institute, “so literally where the rubber hits the road is the world’s cities.

This commitment became clear upon the signing of the final Paris Agreement on December 12th. In his address to COP members during the signing of the Paris Agreement, Ronan Dantec, spokesperson for UCLG, said

tonight, you have reached an agreement so, starting tomorrow, we commit to do everything we can to take action to achieve it."

Additionally, as cities work to implement climate action policies, they are constantly looking for and finding new ways to address other important issues in addition to climate change. At COP-21, local and regional leaders emphasized the link between climate action and other UN initiatives which are already in place. These include Agenda 2030, which details the UN's Sustainable Development Goals, and Habitat III, which focuses on sustainable urban development.

Ultimately, we believe that the climate and development agendas are one and the same, and that they represent a single, common international obligation," notes Dantec.

When our class left Paris after the first week, the outcome of COP-21 was far from certain. At that time, there was so much left to be negotiated, with hundreds of brackets remaining in the draft text. Many were skeptical if an international agreement would ever be reached.

On the flight back, a friend of mine asked me to describe my experience at COP-21 in one word.  “I’m hopeful,” I said. “Not hopeful because of what might happen internationally, but hopeful because I know that the world’s cities will be taking action no matter what.”

A week later, on December 12th, while all eyes were on the international delegations as the historic Paris Agreement was signed, the mayors of the world’s cities quietly began another day of work, likely feeling proud of their role as the unsung heroes in the fight against climate change.